Explorar o código

📝 docs(qa): update user search and filtering test documentation

- 更新测试架构问题描述,明确后端集成测试语法错误和变量声明问题
- 细化前端测试环境配置问题,包括document未定义和userEvent.setup()问题
- 调整E2E测试配置问题描述,指明Playwright test.describe()调用位置错误
- 更新质量评分从65降至60,反映测试问题严重性增加
- 明确测试文件具体代码行引用,便于定位问题
- 完善性能测试防抖优化说明,补充300ms延迟信息
- 细化可靠性和可维护性评估,强调测试架构对回归测试能力的影响
- 更新即时修复建议,明确三个关键测试文件的问题位置
yourname hai 2 meses
pai
achega
c937028e1c

+ 22 - 20
docs/qa/gates/002.001-user-search-and-advanced-filtering.yml

@@ -2,34 +2,34 @@ schema: 1
 story: "002.001"
 story_title: "用户搜索和高级过滤功能"
 gate: CONCERNS
-status_reason: "功能实现完整但测试架构存在严重问题,需要修复测试才能确保质量"
+status_reason: "功能实现完整但测试架构存在严重问题,后端集成测试语法错误,前端组件测试环境配置问题"
 reviewer: "Quinn (Test Architect)"
-updated: "2025-09-15T15:30:00Z"
+updated: "2025-09-16T01:15:00Z"
 
 waiver: { active: false }
 
 top_issues:
   - id: "TEST-001"
     severity: high
-    finding: "后端集成测试存在路径引用错误和模块找不到问题"
-    suggested_action: "修复测试文件中的模块导入路径"
+    finding: "后端集成测试存在语法错误(await在非async函数中)和mockCrudService变量重复声明"
+    suggested_action: "修复测试文件语法错误和变量声明问题"
     suggested_owner: dev
   - id: "TEST-002"
     severity: high
-    finding: "前端UsersPage组件完全缺少测试覆盖"
-    suggested_action: "添加前端组件测试和过滤功能单元测试"
+    finding: "前端UsersPage组件测试存在document未定义和userEvent.setup()环境问题"
+    suggested_action: "修复前端测试环境配置和userEvent初始化问题"
     suggested_owner: dev
   - id: "TEST-003"
-    severity: medium
-    finding: "E2E测试配置存在语法错误"
-    suggested_action: "修复Playwright测试文件配置"
+    severity: high
+    finding: "E2E测试配置存在语法错误(Playwright test.describe()调用位置错误)"
+    suggested_action: "修复Playwright测试文件配置和导入问题"
     suggested_owner: dev
 
-quality_score: 65
-expires: "2025-09-29T00:00:00Z"
+quality_score: 60
+expires: "2025-09-30T00:00:00Z"
 
 evidence:
-  tests_reviewed: 1
+  tests_reviewed: 3
   risks_identified: 3
   trace:
     ac_covered: [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]
@@ -41,20 +41,22 @@ nfr_validation:
     notes: "认证和授权机制正常,无安全漏洞"
   performance:
     status: PASS
-    notes: "搜索防抖优化,性能良好"
+    notes: "搜索防抖优化(300ms),性能良好"
   reliability:
     status: CONCERNS
-    notes: "测试覆盖不足影响可靠性评估"
+    notes: "测试架构问题严重影响可靠性评估"
   maintainability:
     status: CONCERNS
-    notes: "测试问题会影响代码的可维护性"
+    notes: "测试问题严重影响代码的可维护性和回归测试能力"
 
 recommendations:
   immediate:
-    - action: "修复后端集成测试的模块引用问题"
-      refs: ["src/server/api/__integration_tests__/users.integration.test.ts"]
-    - action: "添加前端UsersPage组件测试"
-      refs: ["src/client/admin/pages/Users.tsx"]
+    - action: "彻底修复后端集成测试语法错误和mock问题"
+      refs: ["src/server/api/__integration_tests__/users.integration.test.ts:32-132"]
+    - action: "修复前端组件测试环境配置问题"
+      refs: ["src/client/admin/pages/__tests__/Users.test.tsx:127-164"]
+    - action: "修复E2E测试配置语法错误"
+      refs: ["tests/e2e/specs/**/*.spec.ts:4-10"]
   future:
-    - action: "完善过滤功能的边界情况测试"
+    - action: "完善过滤功能的边界情况测试和集成测试"
       refs: ["src/server/utils/generic-crud.service.ts:90-141"]

+ 6 - 6
docs/stories/002.001.story.md

@@ -181,13 +181,13 @@ const response = await userClient.$get({
 
 ## QA Results
 
-### Review Date: 2025-09-15
+### Review Date: 2025-09-16
 
 ### Reviewed By: Quinn (Test Architect)
 
 ### Code Quality Assessment
 
-功能实现完整,用户搜索和高级过滤功能已按需求完成。前端界面设计良好,用户体验合理。后端成功迁移到通用CRUD架构,保持了API兼容性。主要问题在于测试架构存在严重缺陷。
+功能实现完整,用户搜索和高级过滤功能已按需求完成。前端界面设计良好,用户体验合理。后端成功迁移到通用CRUD架构,保持了API兼容性。主要问题在于测试架构存在严重缺陷,包括语法错误、环境配置问题和测试框架兼容性问题
 
 ### Refactoring Performed
 
@@ -197,14 +197,14 @@ const response = await userClient.$get({
 
 - Coding Standards: ✓ 基本符合编码规范,存在一些lint警告但无阻塞性问题
 - Project Structure: ✓ 项目结构合理,文件组织清晰
-- Testing Strategy: ✗ 测试策略执行不足,存在严重测试问题
+- Testing Strategy: ✗ 测试策略执行严重不足,存在多个测试框架配置问题
 - All ACs Met: ✓ 所有验收标准均已实现
 
 ### Improvements Checklist
 
-- [ ] 修复后端集成测试模块引用问题 (src/server/api/__integration_tests__/users.integration.test.ts)
-- [ ] 添加前端UsersPage组件测试 (src/client/admin/pages/Users.tsx)
-- [ ] 修复E2E测试配置语法错误 (tests/e2e/目录)
+- [ ] 修复后端集成测试语法错误和mock问题 (src/server/api/__integration_tests__/users.integration.test.ts)
+- [ ] 修复前端组件测试环境配置问题 (src/client/admin/pages/__tests__/Users.test.tsx)
+- [ ] 修复E2E测试配置语法错误 (tests/e2e/specs/目录)
 - [ ] 完善过滤功能的边界情况测试
 
 ### Security Review